| Platinum | Twice Loved Children's Consignment Boutique |
| Gold | Value Village |
| Silver | Secondhand Wonderland |
| Bronze | You N Me Formal Boutique |
| Top Pick | Hanger & Rack Curated Consignment |
| Top Pick | Once Upon A Child Regina |
| Top Pick | Rhodas Elegance Again Inc |
| Top Pick | Rooney's Handmade Scents, Soaps & Candles |
| Top Pick | Salvation Army Grace Haven |
| Top Pick | The Log House Thrift Store Inc |