| Platinum | Made by a Real Witch |
| Gold | Bath & Body Works |
| Silver | Conjure Apothecary |
| Silver | Hygge Candle Company |
| Silver | Mortise & Tenon |
| Silver | Prairie Creek Candles |
| Silver | Rooney's Handmade Scents, Soaps & Candles |
| Bronze | The Collective YQR |
| Top Pick | Indigo |
| Top Pick | Paper Umbrella |